Modernistic vs Nextnature Architecture

Van Mensvoort
July 19th 2007

wtc nextnature

While the Freedom tower, replacing the WTC twin towers, is being constructed at ground zero, I still enjoy looking at some of the earlier submitted proposals. They tend to be more elementary, serene, elegant or characteristic than the final design, which had to deal with all the practicalities and compromises between all the stakeholders.

Especially Lars Spuybroek's (NOX) proposal Oblique, created shortly after the WTC attacks, is like a schoolbook illustration showing the differences between the 20th century architecture and the architecture of our time. Spuybroek envisions a swirling cluster of porous towers rising from Ground Zero, lifting the street into the sky, while allowing sunlight to the street level: 'Elevators form a highly complex structure of diagonals where at some platforms more than five or six different cores come together to form larger public areas. It is this network of elevators which makes the buildings not just a new type of tower, but more like a new type of urbanism.'

Twice the same building, but in a different era. Both illustrative for their time.

Share your thoughts and join the technology debate!


Comments are members only. Login to your account and join the technology debate.

Not a member? Join us
Posted 21/07/2007 – 14:03

Couldn't agree more Hendrik-Jan.

Hendrik-Jan Grievink
Posted 20/07/2007 – 02:59

I saw this design emerging from day to day in the period that Spuybroek used Rem Koolhaas' and OMA's office space just around the corner from where I lived. Up until the day a BIG-scale model of this final design stood in the main space. I think it is amazing and Spuybroek is about one of the most interesting architects of our time. The guy should build BIG cos all of his smaller-scale architecture lloks like pathetic turds...

Posted 19/07/2007 – 21:53

It seems tobe architectural week at

Should men be able to give birth to children?

Joyce Nabuurs: To me this question seems to be a logical next step in the emancipation movement of the past century. More and more women entered the workspace, but the responsibility for pregnancy and childrearing remained female.

Already a member? Login.