How Google Maps Solves Borders Issues

Alessia Andreotti
June 14th 2014

Google Maps drew up three different topographical plans of Crimea: one for visitors from Ukraine, another one for Russian users; and the third on the international version of the site.

“People generally assume that, well, science is just objective, and what we do in cartography is represent the world ‘out there’. But it’s never as clear cut,” explains  Christine Leuenberger, Cornell University professor who researches politics and cartography. “Maps are always selective. You always have to omit as much as you include. So they’re always political. It’s impossible to construct an apolitical map.”

So, Google decided which geopolitical truth to tell you based on which country's version of Google you are using. For people located in Ukraine, Google Maps left Crimea as a part of Ukraine, as it looked before Russia’s invasion. But it changed the map for users accessing the site from Russia, showing Crimea as separate from Ukraine with a thick line. International visitors see a version with a dotted line, the sign of a disputed border.

In mapmaking, who establishes where the borders fall?

Find more on BBC Travel

Share your thoughts and join the technology debate!public: 1

Be the first to comment

What is your view on the coronavirus?


Siri Beerends: I really embrace the idea that viruses can teach us a lesson in modesty. It is necessary that our position as the dominant species on the planet is being challenged. I also agree that it is a mistake to think that we are becoming Gods. But unfortunately, this is actually what is happening now. Corona doesn’t teach us to be modest, it teaches us how we can -as quickly as possible- go back to business as usual: saving our capitalistic economy.

Comment
Already a member? Login.